Pool resurfacing vs replacement

Quick comparison

Here is a side-by-side look at the two options. Resurfacing is the right choice for the vast majority of pool owners, but there are rare situations where replacement is necessary.

When resurfacing is the better choice

Resurfacing makes sense whenever the pool shell is structurally sound but the surface has deteriorated. Consider resurfacing if:

• The surface has cracks, chips, staining, or rough texture
• The pool looks dated and you want a fresh appearance
• You are having difficulty maintaining water chemistry due to a porous or damaged surface
• Blistering or peeling is visible on a fiberglass pool
• Plaster is chalking or flaking on a concrete pool
• You want to update the color or finish of your pool
• You want to avoid the cost and disruption of a full construction project

For more on what this costs, see our pool resurfacing cost guide.

When replacement makes more sense

Full pool replacement is a major construction project that is only warranted in specific situations:

• The pool shell has major structural failure — shifting, heaving, or large cracks through the structure
• You want a completely different pool shape, size, depth, or layout
• The plumbing system is extensively damaged and needs to be entirely replaced
• You are already doing a major backyard renovation that involves regrading or redesigning the space

If you are unsure whether your pool's problems are surface-level or structural, send us photos. We will tell you honestly which option makes sense — and if resurfacing is not the right solution, we will say so.

What pool resurfacing involves

Professional pool resurfacing restores the surface without touching the pool shell or plumbing:

1. Assessment — We inspect the pool, identify all surface damage, and determine the scope of work.
2. Draining and preparation — The pool is drained, cleaned, and the existing surface is sanded and repaired. Cracks, chips, and blisters are addressed.
3. Resurfacing — A new professional-grade coating is applied in your chosen color with optional speckle patterns.
4. Curing and refill — The coating cures and the pool is ready to refill within the timeline we provide, typically two to four days total.

We also resurface pool decks, steps, coping, diving boards, slides, and hot tubs and spas.

What pool replacement involves

Full pool replacement is a significant construction project:

1. Demolition — The existing pool is broken up and removed, often requiring heavy equipment like excavators and jackhammers.
2. Excavation — The site is regraded and prepared for the new pool shell.
3. Construction — A new pool is built — either a new gunite shell is poured or a prefabricated fiberglass shell is set.
4. Plumbing and equipment — New plumbing, pumps, filters, and other equipment are installed.
5. Finishing — The pool is finished, decking is installed, and landscaping is restored.

This process typically takes several weeks and involves multiple contractors. Your yard is a construction zone for the duration, and fencing, landscaping, and hardscaping often need to be repaired or replaced.

Frequently asked questions

Should I resurface or replace my pool?

In most cases, resurfacing is the better choice. It costs significantly less, takes days instead of weeks, and restores the look and function of your existing pool. Replacement is only necessary if the pool shell is structurally failing.

How long does pool resurfacing last?

A professionally resurfaced pool typically lasts 10 to 15 years or more depending on the coating system, water chemistry maintenance, and pool usage.

Can you resurface a pool that has been empty for years?

Often yes, but it depends on the condition of the shell. Pools that have been empty for extended periods may have additional cracking or shifting that needs to be assessed. Send us photos and we can advise.

Does resurfacing fix pool leaks?

Surface-level cracks and porosity that cause minor water loss are often resolved during resurfacing. However, structural cracks or plumbing leaks require separate repair. We will identify any issues during our assessment.